CSL Forums

Can't stop a club doing that Boots as its an internal decision by players, coaches and the club.... The Windsor debate is that they have an A team in a C grade division as opposed to playing A team players in the C grade team... The net effect MAY be similar but its a different issue. It will NEVER ...

Spoke to a ref about it at the weekend and his view was the game should be replayed so it seems protocol / process has been followed...
Not sure about 5 points to follow though!!!!
Gonna be a firecracker of a game no matter and time to move on

A fair draw for the 1A teams...... All should feel Round 4 is within their reach but always bananas skins ESPECIALLY as the round is over the long weekend and there will be some player (s) at some teams who will be away....... may be a great evener! Even better is at least 3 non 1A teams are guarant...

Good calling Roswil!! Have to say that Grads Blue are going to struggle this season. Whacked by 10 goals on a tiny pitch with a poor surface is a snap shot of how poor they were yesterday. It will be carnage against the top 4 away on bigger, better surfaces and the enthusiasm mid season will wane if...

Grads Blue v Mt Barker (Mt Barker by the odd goal in a low tech battle) Mercedes v Grads Red (Draw.... I see a red card or two in the tea leaves) Pulteney v Rostrevor (Rostrevor by 4, as long as all Pulteney players are eligible, otherwise by 3 ;) ) Sacred Heart v Unley (Sacred Heart, just, in a din...

The ref has already offered WG's opposition this weekend the choice of a 3-0 win after 55 mins or having to play the 90 minutes for the potential fielding of a registered player with a name spelt wrong who may not have a red card wrongly applied.... WG will be allowed to start the game with 12 playe...

As said before... wrong decision by the ref but the clerical error would have led to the game being forfeited eventually. Should have been sorted in the disciplinary office not by a ref. Questions: 1 - Why did the ref have the team sheet on him at the 75 min mark? Have never seen a ref mark the team...

What a mess.... IF the facts are as discussed then the rules would mean that WG will have to forfeit the game due to fielding a player not on the team sheet.... A harsh result for a clerical error but a rule never the less.... HOWEVER, the referee should not have offered Rostrevor ANY option and I w...

Seriously hope the game wasn't forfeited due to a clerical error on the team sheet...... There has to be more to it..... Surely even to the letter of the law, the game should have been played out and then the rules, officialdom etc. is applied. Is a ref allowed to make that call in the rules? (serio...